In
Competition Mode: Micromax Canvas HD and Samsung Galaxy Grand
Micromax A116 Canvas
HD and Samsung Galaxy Grand Duos I9082 fight it out
By : Tushar Kanwar
The
first three months of the year have seen so much action around mobile flagship
devices, yet the launch of two devices- the Micromax A116 Canvas HD and the
Samsung Galaxy Grand Duos I9082 - has brought the focus back on the mid-range
segment. Both these devices pack in 5-inch displays and dual-SIM (with
dual-standby) capabilities, run the Android 4.1 Jellybean version, and offer
buyers similar specs in terms of camera (8MP), battery and memory
specifications. Does the Samsung juggernaut steamroll the more competitively
priced Canvas HD, or does the local underdog prevail? I pit both phones against
each other on 5 key parameters to see which one triumphs.
Display: Score one for the Canvas HD, which features a 1280 x 720 pixel
display in its five-inch screen as compared to the lower 480x800 pixels on the
Grand. As a result, images, text and videos are sharper, though contrast issues
make the experience seem a tad washed out when compared to the Grand. Has to be
said that despite the lower resolution, the Grand display isn't bad, per se,
but scrimping on a 720p display when a far cheaper handset packs one in seems
odd. Winner: Canvas HD, by a
whisker.
Build Quality: While both phones make heavy use of plastic in their
design, the Grand felt better and more refined in the hand, not to mention
thinner, almost like a budget version of the SIII. While the Galaxy Grand is
wider, the Canvas HD is longer, so it sits better in smaller-to-medium-sized
hands. In either case, both devices punch above their weight and feel a lot
more expensive than their price suggests - especially true with the Canvas HD
which feels leagues better in the hand than previous Micromax phones. Winner:
Galaxy Grand, for its refinement and
the extremely handy flip cover that's included in the retail pack.
Performance: In terms of sheer horsepower, the quad-core chip under the
Canvas HD's hood blows the dual-core-based Grand out of the water, even though
you really have to push the two devices to see the extra grunt that the Canvas
HD packs come into play. That said, the Grand is no slouch, and both handsets
breeze through everyday tasks with ease, and you only see the Grand stutter
under heavy multitasking and some of the latest graphics intensive games. Winner:
Canvas HD, for packing in so much more
for less.
Interface: A thinly skinned, almost-pure Android experience vs.
Samsung's proprietary TouchWiz skin? Ordinarily, I'd prefer the former, but in
this case, the better social sharing options and neat software add-ons (like
the split-screen view and the gesture support that's usually to be found on
their more premium devices) tilt the discussion in favor of the Grand. Winner:
The Samsung Grand
Camera: Both cameras perform well in well-lit conditions, but come
evening, the Canvas HD's low light performance takes a massive hit - not so
with the Grand. In fact, you could possibly consider the Canvas HD's camera its
biggest drawback. Winner: The Samsung
Grand.
Battery Life: Battery life for both is middling in that they both last a
day (just about), though even with the extra hardware that the Canvas HD packs,
it doesn't drain out quite as quickly as the Grand does. Considering that the
Grand has a large 2000mAh battery, this is surprising. Winner: Canvas HD
Media Playback: With good playback support in both handsets, playing
movies is a cinch on either. Keep in mind though that the onboard storage and
expandability on the Grand is double that of the Canvas HD, so if you're a
media maven who absolutely must have a bunch of movies and numerous playlists
wherever you go, the Grand is a better choice. My out-and-out choice for music
and audio quality would go to the Grand, and the great pair of included
headphones help its cause a fair bit. Even though the Grand packs in a lower
resolution screen, the movie watching experience on the Grand is leagues ahead
of the Canvas HD thanks to the great sound quality and high contrast levels. Winner: The Samsung Grand.
Price: Things are neck and neck for the moment, but here's the clincher
— the Canvas HD is cheaper than the Grand by about Rs. 8,000! Is the Samsung
branding and the promise of better after-sales worth that much? Not in my
books! Winner Canvas HD.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The
above is not my article but an article
written by Tushar Kanwar of the Business World. But I take off from the
article. Micromax has taken on a David who took on a Goliath itself. In short
Samsung has taken on Nokia and won hands down. Now Micromax wants to do a
Samsung on Samsung itself.
Samsung
has distanced itself from others in the smartphone, Tablets and other
technology driven mobile phone business. It emerged as a market leader through
out the world. Micromax the smart Indian Mobile manufacturer has latched onto
the same platform albeit with a difference. Micromax wants to be a low priced
Samsung. In other words it is a poor man’s Samsung. It offers the same features,
same quality and is almost the same as Samsung but at a very different, low
price, affordable price point. Micromax ploy is proving to be successful and it
is claiming a sale over a million Canvas HD smartphones.
This
again proves that single point agenda of attention on the market leader with a
fierce focus on product benefits, better value proposition with a low price is
a one strategy that pays – always.